Great, thanks Jim, Victor. On Mon, May 16, 2016, 6:41 PM Victor Rodriguez <vm.rod25(a)gmail.com>

> > Sure Jim > > I will sync with Avraham on this > > Thanks for the support > > Regards > > Victor Rodriguez > > On May 16, 2016 6:16 PM, "Chamings, James E" <jim.chamings(a)intel.com> > wrote: >> >> Hi, >> >> >> >> The overall goal of bundles is to provide a collective functional >> capability. So really, the example of message-broker-rabbitmq is not

>> in this case; it was mostly included that way as a part of the

>> deployment in ClearLinux and really should have just been called >> ‘message-broker’ or even ‘openstack-message-broker’. >> >> >> >> For this one, since mosquitto is relatively unique to iot, I would

>> to see it included in the ‘iot’ bundle directly, as part of that

>> technology. Your point about wanting to run a server standalone is >> well-taken, however, so may I suggest ‘iot-message-broker’ as a new

>> that includes mosquitto/mqtt, and that is then included as you have >> suggested in ‘iot’. >> >> >> >> Having a generic bundle of message brokers would not be particularly >> useful, since very very few people would ever want to have both

>> the same place. >> >> >> >> Summary: >> >> 1) New bundle: ‘iot-message-broker’, contents ‘mosquitto’. >> >> 2) Add ‘include(iot-message-broker)’ to ‘iot’ bundle. >> >> >> >> [ Victor, if there’s no issue with this layout, feel free to do it up

>> merge it… ] >> >> >> >> Cheers, >> >> Jim Chamings >> >> >> >> >> >> From: Dev <dev-bounces(a)lists.clearlinux.org> on behalf of Abraham Arce >> <xe1gyq(a)gmail.com> >> Date: Monday, May 16, 2016 at 8:35 AM >> To: Victor Rodriguez <vm.rod25(a)gmail.com> >> Cc: "dev(a)lists.clearlinux.org" <dev(a)lists.clearlinux.org> >> Subject: Re: [Dev] Bundle Mqtt Broker >> >> >> >> Arjan, Victor, >> >> Thanks for your quick response and comments... >> >> >> First, the reason for my request is we are going to use Clear Linux as

>> Learning Platform for Cloud as part of "The IoT Learning Initiative" >> https://theiotlearninginitiative.gitbooks.io/master/content/ >> https://twitter.com/IoTLearningInit >> >> Second, by looking at the List of Bundles we have a couple which looks >> related: >> >> >> Bundle message-broker-rabbitmq >> >>

>> >> Bundle iot >> https://github.com/clearlinux/clr-bundles/blob/master/bundles/iot >> >> I don't think neither iot bundle nor lamp-basic are the right place to >> include Mosquitto Mqtt Broker, I might want only to have Clear Linux

>> work as a messaging broker alone. If we want to follow a convention to

>> Victor Morales maintains with rabbitmq, then we could probably call it >> "message-broker-mosquitto" >> >> >> They are part of "Messaging Protocols" / "Message Brokers" / >> "Connectivity Protocol" and since IoT is having a big impact on them,

>> people called them "IoT Protocols". >> Should we start creating a bundle with some of the previous names to >> group them? how about "message-brokers" since we are dealing with

>> application and not the protocol and once we have this new bundle we

>> make iot to "include(message-brokers)" bundle? >> >> We can start with Mosquitto for now and add other protocols as required >> in future, in summary the proposal is: >> >> message-broker-mosquitto New Bundle >> >> + mosquitto >> >> >> >> message-brokers New Bundle >> + include(message-broker-mosquitto) >> + include(message-broker-rabbitmq) >> >> iot Modified Bundle >> ... >> + include(message-brokers) >> >> >> >> Please let me know your comments... >> >> >> >> Best Regards >> >> Abraham >> >> >> >> On Mon, May 16, 2016 at 8:27 AM, Victor Rodriguez <vm.rod25(a)gmail.com> >> wrote: >> >> Hi >> >> As far as I can see mosquito provides a lightweight method of >> carrying out messaging using a publish/subscribe model for the IoT >> devices. >> >> So Clear Linux might have an IoT bundle; however, in my opinion, it >> might not be the best place for it. We might need to put this in a >> server bundle , like LAMP ( just saying one ) . But sure a bundle >> from the server point of view with more protocols that the industry >> uses to communicate IoT devices. >> >> Abraham , do you know if there is more of these protocols that might >> be worth to include . Would be nice to have a bundle that supports the >> most used IoT communication protocols. >> >> Best regards >> >> Victor Rodriguez >> >> >> >> >> On Mon, May 16, 2016 at 8:00 AM, Arjan van de Ven <

>> wrote: >> > On 5/15/2016 10:37 PM, Abraham Arce wrote: >> >> >> >> Hi Clear Linux Team, >> >> >> >> How possible is it you can integrate Mosquitto Mqtt Broker as part

>> >> a >> >> bundle? >> >> Thanks! >> >> >> >> http://mosquitto.org/download/ >> >> >> > >> > since bundles are use/functionality based.... for us to know where to >> > put >> > it.... >> > >> > How would you use this component ? >> >> > _______________________________________________ >> > Dev mailing list >> > Dev(a)lists.clearlinux.org >> > https://lists.clearlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/dev >> >>